The Starway Diner

Reviews

• Robert S.

  star star star star_border star_border 15 June 2026

  Waitresses are nice.
  Food is expensive
  Atmosphere is very nice
  It just seems they close whenever they feel like it.
  They post 11pm on Saturdays
  And I have gone there at 9 PM
  And the menu is very limited or i am told. Sorry(it's slow, it's raining, it's snowing) we will be closing soon and it's only 9 pm.
  I cannot plan to have a meal there because you never know when they are closing.
  If you post 11pm unless it's a blizzard, you need to keep your hours

• Scott M.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 8 June 2026

  My GF and I decided to stop here on our way back to NYC because this place had an outdoor patio.young  We were seated next to a family of ten with kids. The kids were getting restless and we overheard the mother complaining that they had been waiting over a hour. When their food arrived 15 minutes later it was almost all wrong and the waitress was incredibly rude about correcting it.   Roughly 15 mins. later I asked a short stocky guy who was helping bus tables if he could check in on our food. The guy said "It'll be here when its ready!" I was trying to be nice and reply that the only reason that I asked is that we could take it to go, he then said "Go find your waitress, we are very busy and you need to wait"."
  
  At this point my GF and I both told him never mind please cancel the order. This guy (looking straight out of work release with a  inch cheek scar as an accessory) got directly in my face and told me to get the hell out of his restaurant. He then had the balls as we were leaving to demand we pay $3 for the crappy coffee. At this point I told him where I'd like to shove the $3 but my GF gave it to him, looking to diffuse the situation.
  
  This place is a disaster. I felt awful for the poor family next to me, and the little thug that got in my face (he opened the cash register so I'm assuming hes at least part owner) is better off going back to serving fellow prisoners at lockup.   I wish I was exaggerating what a terrible experience this was. Place should be shut down.

• Colleen N.

  star star star star_border star_border 2 June 2026

  My dad had the Reuben and said it was delicious.  I had the buffalo chicken wrap.  I don't recommend getting this.  It had fried chicken tenders in it, but there wasn't much buffalo sauce, and what was there was watery and leaked out of the wrap.  As a result, the sandwich didn't have much flavor.  I liked that you could get curly fries.  The waitress was nice, but it took awhile for the food to come out, and we didn't order anything that should've taken more than 10 minutes.  The cole slaw that came with the sandwiches was just ok.

• Meghan P.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 24 May 2026

  Looks good but waited forever to order...  we got drinks and menu fast but waited and waited to order.  Foid not that great.. there were few waitresses and not many people so I'm perplexed to know what caused the wait.  Other dieting patrons also waited forever..   dont adk for coffee refil..

• Nola W.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 19 May 2026

  TERRIBLE staff and breakfast. Stay far away or go to Mcd's right next to it.